Skip to main content
Logo
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Results
    • Alan Kolodny
    • Rashon Murrill
    • Testimonials
  • Practice Areas
    • Auto Accidents
    • Trucking Accidents
      • Tanker Truck Accidents
      • Tow Truck Accidents
      • Underride Truck Accidents
    • Slip & Fall Accidents
    • Railroad Accidents
    • Maritime Accidents
      • Boat Accidents
      • Dive Boat Accidents
    • Delivery Accidents
  • Service Areas
    • Angleton, TX
    • Brazoria, TX
    • Houston, TX
    • Katy, TX
    • Lake Jackson, TX
    • League City, TX
      • Car Accident
    • Pearland, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • Pasadena, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • Sugar Land, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • The Woodlands, TX
      • Car Accidents
  • Articles
  • Contact Us
(713) 532-4474 Call Now

The Super Scoop

Home > The Super Scoop
Attorney Portrait
May 18, 2018 | By Alan Kolodny | Read Time: 2 minutes | Jones Act

Usually, it is easy to determine what is called a maritime accident. If it falls under the maritime rubric, then the case will be heard in federal court and the Jones Act will apply. If it is not a maritime case, then it may be heard in state court and the Jones Act will not apply. The case of Stewart v. Duntra Construction, decided by the United States Supreme Court in 2005, was such a case in which determining whether there was a “maritime” accident was not so simple.

The Big Dig

During the 1990s, the state of Massachusetts sought to extend the Massachusetts Turnpike by digging a tunnel underneath Boston Harbor. This project was known as the “Big Dig.” To assist in digging up the tunnel, the state employed Duntra Construction, the owners of the “Super Scoop.” The Super Scoop was a massive dredge that floated on the water and had a clamshell scoop suspended underneath the water.

The Super Scoop was manned by a captain and crew, but had limited self propulsion. It seemed to be a quasi seafaring vessel.

Duntra Construction hired Willard Stewart, a marine engineer, to work the mechanical aspects of the Super Scoop. While working near the Super Scoop’s engine, a move by the Super Scoop caused him to fall through an opening and land headfirst. This caused Stewart to suffer a serious injury, and as a result, Stewart sued for negligence.

Specifically, Stewart sued for compensation under the Jones Act, claiming that he was a “seaman” under the Act. Alternatively, Stewart sued for negligence under the Longshore and Harbor Workers Compensation Act or LHWCA.

Jones Act and LHWCA Suits

Under the Jones Act, an employee is barred from suing the company for negligence because it is assumed that the plaintiff assumed the risk of vessel employment. Under the LHCWA, someone can sue for negligence but cannot be a member of the veseel’s crew.

District Court

At trial, the District Court ruled that the Super Scoop is not a “vessel” under the Jones Act. Although it floats on the water, the Court noted that its purpose was to dredge. However, it would qualify as a vessel under the LHCWA because it floated, which is confusing. The Court ruled that Duntra is not obligated to Stewart because, at the time of him hurting himself, Duntra was acting in an employer capacity and not in an owner capacity.

The case eventually made it to the United States Supreme Court.

Supreme Court Case

The Supreme Court, citing previous case law, concluded that it was a vessel under the definition. The idea is that the definition of vessel is based on its ability to float. The primary purpose is not relevant. Nor does that vessel need self propulsion. The Super Scoop’s mode of travel is not relevant. Therefore Stewart, as a member of the crew, was entitled to sue for compensation under the Jones Act.

Have you been injured in a maritime accident? Speak with a law firm that is both experienced and knowledgeable in maritime law. Contact the Kolodny law firm.   

Author Photo
Alan Kolodny

Alan Kolodny is committed to representing injured clients in Texas and throughout the United States. Alan earned his B.A. from Rice University and his J.D. from Southern Methodist University.

He focuses his practice on representing plaintiffs in personal injury cases involving the following matters: maritime and offshore accidents, including those under the Jones Act; automobile and 18-wheeler truck accidents; and industrial site accidents, work-related accidents, and claims for injured railroad workers under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act.

Rate this Post
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading...
  • Share

    • Contact Us
    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Questions about Your Case?
713-532-4474
Mon. - Fri.: 9:00am - 6:00pm
akolodny@fko-law.com
  • 1011 Augusta Dr., Ste 111 Houston, TX 77057
  • Contact us now!
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

No win, no fee

GET IT TOUCH
  • © 2025 Kolodny Law Firm.
  •  | All Rights Reserved.
  •  | Disclaimer
  •  | Sitemap
Site By:

The content on this website is offered as a public service by Kolodny Law Firm and is meant for informational purposes only.

The content on this website does not provide legal advice for any specific situation nor does it create an attorney-client relationship between any reader and any attorney at Kolodny Law Firm.

  • Contact Us for a Consultation Schedule your free consultation.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Client movie

713-532-4474
  • Español