Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā  Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā  Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā Ā  Skip to main content
Logo
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Results
    • Alan Kolodny
    • Rashon Murrill
    • Testimonials
  • Practice Areas
    • Auto Accidents
    • Trucking Accidents
      • Tanker Truck Accidents
      • Tow Truck Accidents
      • Underride Truck Accidents
    • Slip & Fall Accidents
    • Railroad Accidents
    • Maritime Accidents
      • Boat Accidents
      • Dive Boat Accidents
    • Delivery Accidents
  • Service Areas
    • Angleton, TX
    • Brazoria, TX
    • Houston, TX
    • Katy, TX
    • Lake Jackson, TX
    • League City, TX
      • Car Accident
    • Pearland, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • Pasadena, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • Sugar Land, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • The Woodlands, TX
      • Car Accidents
  • Articles
  • Contact Us
(713) 532-4474 Call Now

Maritime Law: Federal Appeals Court Ruling Limits Scope of Product Liability Claims

Home > Maritime Law: Federal Appeals Court Ruling Limits Scope of Product Liability Claims
Attorney Portrait
Feb 15, 2021 | By Alan Kolodny | Read Time: 2 minutes | Maritime Law

As reported by The Waterways Journal, a recent federal court ruling limits the scope of maritime-related product liability claims. In the case of Ortega Garcia v. United States, the Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit found that under maritime law only end users and intended customers are covered by product liability protections, not bystanders. Here, our Houston, TX maritime lawyers highlight the most important things you need to know about the court’s decision and explain the implications. 

Case Analysis: Garcia v. Ortega Garcia v. United States

Background and Facts 

While on patrol near Brownsville, Texas, a United States Coast Guard (USCG) vessel struck and killed a woman who was swimming across a shipping channel. According to court records, the woman, a Mexican national, was attempting to immigrate to the United States. A representative of her family filed a wrongful death claim on the grounds of negligence and product liability. Among other legal claims, her heirs argued that the design of the vessel was defective because it made it too difficult for crewmembers to see what was in front of them. 

The Decision of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeal

The courts separated the product liability from all other legal claims being pursued by the family. On review, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed the product liability lawsuit. The claim, which was filed against a Washington based manufacturing company called Safe Boats International LLC, was thrown out on the grounds that the family did not have standing to sue. 

In these circumstances, the victim was a ā€œbystanderā€ā€”meaning she had no direct legal  relationship with the vessel’s manufacturer. The appeals court ruled that under maritime law, a bystander does not have a product liability claim. Only customers and other end-users have the standing to bring a product liability suit against a vessel’s manufacturer. 

The Implications of the Ruling

The specific facts in this case are unique—so much so, that the appeals court noted that it was ruling on a ā€œcase of first impression.ā€ As defined by the Cornell Legal Information Institute, a case of first impression is one that presents a legal issue that has not yet been decided in a particular jurisdiction. Nonetheless, this decision could have important implications for other product liability claims brought under U.S. maritime law. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals has narrowed the parties that have standing to file a lawsuit. 

Call Our Texas Maritime Lawyers for Immediate Legal Help

At the Kolodny Law Firm, our Texas maritime law attorneys are strong and justice-driven advocates for injured victims and their families. Your rights matter. Our law firm will take aggressive action to get you and your loved ones full financial compensation. If you have any questions about maritime law and product liability claims, we will get you answers. Contact our team right away to get your free, no commitment case review. From our legal office in Houston, we handle maritime law claims throughout Texas. 

Author Photo
Alan Kolodny

Alan Kolodny is committed to representing injured clients in Texas and throughout the United States. Alan earned his B.A. fromĀ Rice UniversityĀ and his J.D. fromĀ Southern Methodist University.

He focuses his practice on representing plaintiffs in personal injury cases involving the following matters: maritime and offshore accidents, including those under the Jones Act; automobile and 18-wheeler truck accidents; and industrial site accidents, work-related accidents, and claims for injured railroad workers under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act.

Rate this Post
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading...
  • Share

    • Contact Us
    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Questions about Your Case?
713-532-4474
Mon. - Fri.: 9:00am - 6:00pm
akolodny@fko-law.com
  • 1011 Augusta Dr., Ste 111 Houston, TX 77057
  • Contact us now!
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

No win, no fee

GET IT TOUCH
  • © 2025 Kolodny Law Firm.
  •  | All Rights Reserved.
  •  | Disclaimer
  •  | Sitemap
Site By:

The content on this website is offered as a public service by Kolodny Law Firm and is meant for informational purposes only.

The content on this website does not provide legal advice for any specific situation nor does it create an attorney-client relationship between any reader and any attorney at Kolodny Law Firm.

  • Contact Us for a Consultation Schedule your free consultation.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Client movie

713-532-4474
  • EspaƱol