Skip to main content
Logo
  • Home
  • Who We Are
    • Results
    • Alan Kolodny
    • Rashon Murrill
  • Practice Areas
    • Auto Accidents
    • Trucking Accidents
      • Tanker Truck Accidents
      • Tow Truck Accidents
      • Underride Truck Accidents
    • Slip & Fall Accidents
    • Railroad Accidents
    • Maritime Accidents
      • Boat Accidents
      • Dive Boat Accidents
    • Delivery Accidents
  • Service Areas
    • Angleton, TX
    • Brazoria, TX
    • Houston, TX
    • Katy, TX
    • Lake Jackson, TX
    • League City, TX
      • Car Accident
    • Pearland, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • Pasadena, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • Sugar Land, TX
      • Car Accidents
    • The Woodlands, TX
      • Car Accidents
  • Articles
  • Contact Us
(713) 532-4474 Call Now

Plaintiff’s Personal Injury Claim Against Cruise Line Dismissed as Untimely Based on Cruise Ticket’s Time Limitation

Home > Plaintiff’s Personal Injury Claim Against Cruise Line Dismissed as Untimely Based on Cruise Ticket’s Time Limitation
Attorney Portrait
Mar 31, 2020 | By Alan Kolodny | Read Time: 2 minutes | Maritime Law

In personal injury cases, whether they are based on maritime law, or state or other federal law, there are generally time limits within which an injured plaintiff must start his or her lawsuit. These time limits are normally referred to as statutes of limitations. In the context of maritime claims and time limits in personal injury cases, there is a provision of federal law that allows owners, masters, managers or agents of vessels to contractually limit the amount of time within which personal injury actions against them can be brought. The provision that specifically recognizes this ability is 46 U.S.C. § 30508(b)(2), which states that the time period for bringing a civil action for personal injury or death can be limited by contract by the owner, master, manager or agent of a vessel transporting passengers or property between United States ports (or United States and international ports). The limitation cannot, under the specific language of the law, be less than a year after the date of the injury or death, however.

Recently, in Melancon v. Carnival Corporation, a federal district court applied this law and dismissed a personal injury claim brought by a passenger against a cruise line. In this case, the plaintiff argued that she lacked the capacity to consent to the terms of the contract, so that the time limitation in the contract did not apply. Based on the facts and the evidence it considered, the court disagreed.

Plaintiff’s Capacity to Consent to the Ticket Terms: Melancon v. Carnival Corporation.

The plaintiff in Melancon v. Carnival Corporation claimed that she was injured shortly after boarding the defendant’s cruise ship. Her ticket contract contained provision that limited the time for bringing personal injury claims. The plaintiff sought to avoid the application of this provision because its application would have made her lawsuit untimely. The crux of the plaintiff’s argument was that because of personal characteristics – she was deaf, mute, visually impaired and functionally illiterate – she lacked the capacity to agree to the terms of the ticket contract.

The court rejected the plaintiff’s argument and dismissed her action. The court stated that while it was sympathetic to the plaintiff’s physical limitations and challenges, the controlling law and facts required that her complaint be dismissed. The court found that:

  • The cruise line had clearly established that, based on the language of the ticket contract, the plaintiff had notice of the fact that the time during which she could bring a personal injury claim against the cruise line was limited, and
  • The plaintiff did not allege that she was induced or somehow fooled or tricked into entering into the ticket contract

Ultimately, the court found that since the plaintiff did not allege that she was incompetent or that she was fraudulently induced into accepting the terms of the ticket contract, she failed to establish a plausible claim that she did not have the capacity to consent to the terms of the ticket contract.

Statutes of limitations in maritime law, along with other legal limitations and requirements, must be complied with in order to bring legal claims that are valid. If you would like to know more about time limits in maritime litigation, or have been injured and would like to discuss a potential claim, contact the experienced maritime team at the Kolodny Law Firm.

Author Photo
Alan Kolodny

Alan Kolodny is committed to representing injured clients in Texas and throughout the United States. Alan earned his B.A. from Rice University and his J.D. from Southern Methodist University.

He focuses his practice on representing plaintiffs in personal injury cases involving the following matters: maritime and offshore accidents, including those under the Jones Act; automobile and 18-wheeler truck accidents; and industrial site accidents, work-related accidents, and claims for injured railroad workers under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act.

Rate this Post
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading...
  • Share

    • Contact Us
    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Questions about Your Case?
713-532-4474
Mon. - Fri.: 9:00am - 6:00pm
akolodny@fko-law.com
  • 1011 Augusta Dr., Ste 111 Houston, TX 77057
  • Contact us now!
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

No win, no fee

GET IT TOUCH
  • © 2025 Kolodny Law Firm.
  •  | All Rights Reserved.
  •  | Disclaimer
  •  | Sitemap
Site By:

The content on this website is offered as a public service by Kolodny Law Firm and is meant for informational purposes only.

The content on this website does not provide legal advice for any specific situation nor does it create an attorney-client relationship between any reader and any attorney at Kolodny Law Firm.

  • Contact Us for a Consultation Schedule your free consultation.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Client movie

713-532-4474
  • Español